The 58-year-old star, who became one of the most recognisable faces of 1990s television through her portrayal of CJ Parker in the lifeguard drama, is said to have already declined an approach from producers working on the new series.
Filming is currently underway in California for the 2026–2027 season of the Fox reboot, which is being developed as a modern reimagining of the original hit show.
"Pamela was approached - and she passed. She's done with that chapter. She's focused on where she's going - not where she's been. That era doesn't define her anymore," a source close to production said.
Producers are aiming to introduce a fresh cast and updated storyline to bring the franchise into a new era, rather than relying on original stars for nostalgia-driven appearances.
The original Baywatch, which ran from 1989 to 2001, became one of the most-watched television series in the world, launching Anderson and co-stars such as David Hasselhoff (Mitch Buchannon) and Carmen Electra (Lani McKenzie) into international fame and defining a generation of 90s pop culture.
Despite the enduring popularity of the franchise, Anderson has previously spoken about stepping away from Hollywood's image-driven expectations, instead focusing in recent years on personal projects, activism, and selective acting roles.
Her decision not to return reflects a broader trend among legacy television stars who are choosing to distance themselves from reboot culture, even as studios increasingly revisit successful formats from past decades.
The new Baywatch project is expected to feature a younger ensemble cast and a more contemporary approach to lifeguard life, though plot details remain tightly under wraps.
While speculation continues around possible cameo appearances from original cast members, Anderson's position appears firm, with insiders suggesting she has "no intention" of revisiting the role in any capacity.
Meanwhile, the Baywatch universe is continuing to expand with more familiar faces returning to the shoreline. Erika Eleniak is set to reprise her role as Shauni McClain in the upcoming Fox sequel series, marking a nostalgic return to the franchise that helped define 1990s television.
In the new series, Shauni is reintroduced as a former lifeguard who has gone on to become a Santa Monica city councilwoman, before heading back to the beach to take part in the annual Beach Games alongside a new generation of lifeguards.
The revival, which is set to air as part of Fox's 2026–2027 lineup, also features Stephen Amell in a leading role, alongside a new ensemble cast including Shay Mitchell, Brooks Nader and Noah Beck - as well as influencer Livvy Dunne featuring in a supporting role as a junior lifeguard.
13°C